Genetics summit holds breath for Chinese baby-editing details

Lack of common sense when attempting to find a 'good' defense against HIV has led to a preventative measure that is worse than simply being able to contract it like everyone else and as if someone claimed that it couldn't get any worse he touched the germ line! And by the way if the father had HIV but due to the way fertilization took place the children wouldn't contract it anyway then what's the point of going through all that risk just to prevent them from getting it? Do they live in an area where HIV positive rapists like to hang out?